This is a cocktail from Jeff “Beachbum” Berry’s The Grog Log. Originally a faux-tropical shot served at Dorrians Red Hand Bar in NYC, it was called a Jamaican Dust.
I asked Jeff how the drink grew larger and changed its name. “The Jamaican Dust was a rum-pineapple-coffee liqueur shot that I just morphed into a taller drink; if memory serves, all I did was cut down the pineapple juice and coffee liqueur a bit, subbed gold Jamaican rum for the unspecified “dark rum” indicated, and shook it instead of using a blender.”
I can see why Jeff used the template for the Castaway. It works, is simple and honestly is one of those drinks that could easily have been served at just about any mid-century Tiki bar.
On a personal note, I opted to use Gosling’s Black Seal rum (from Bermuda) to add a richer character and cut into the sweetness of the pineapple a bit more. I think it works. Let me know what you think.
1.5oz dark rum
0.75oz coffee liqueur
3oz pineapple juice
Garnish: Maraschino cherry speared to pineapple wedge
Shake with ice and strain into hurricane or highball glass filled with crushed ice. Garnish with cherry-pineapple spear.